I read that several years ago after the movie came out. Man there's a lot of material in there for some sequels. I would love to see the Battle of Yonkers made into a movie.
The book was SO much better than the movie; the blind samurai alone could also be a movie. I looked up "The Phantom Major" and have added it to my Goodreads to-read list! Exactly my cup of tea, as I am a huge WW II nut. As a matter of fact, this was what I finished before WWZ:I read that several years ago after the movie came out. Man there's a lot of material in there for some sequels. I would love to see the Battle of Yonkers made into a movie.
Just about finished with: The Phantom Major by Virginia Cowles
Probably every chapter in the WWZ book can stand alone as a movie. I've read literally hundreds of books about WWII and the Phantom Major is absolutely one of the best. What Major Stirling did and accomplished in simply amazing. I should finish it tonight or tomorrow. I believe his story would also make a good movie. Let me know when you finish it and we can compare notes.
It was quite good. I've read prolly 3-4 books about the Naval Campaign for Guadalcanal because it was where we learned how to fight the surface war (after a brutal start at Savo Island) - from night fighting to gunnery to radar etc etc etc, it was our most important learning environment, and those lessons cost us dearly. Hornfischer, IMO, is the finest naval historian working today, but I don't think he will ever do better than what I consider his gold standard; if I had to recommend one book on the naval war in the Pacific it would be this one:How was Neptune's Inferno?
Thanks, I'll probably order both.It was quite good. I've read prolly 3-4 books about the Naval Campaign for Guadalcanal because it was where we learned how to fight the surface war (after a brutal start at Savo Island) - from night fighting to gunnery to radar etc etc etc, it was our most important learning environment, and those lessons cost us dearly. Hornfischer, IMO, is the finest naval historian working today, but I don't think he will ever do better than what I consider his gold standard; if I had to recommend one book on the naval war in the Pacific it would be this one:
![]()
Finished The Phantom Major this morning. Excellent read.Awesome - interested to hear your reviews/thoughts.
North Africa was a fascinating campaign. It was almost the British Army version of Guadalcanal (except that it lasted for three years), with so many of the most storied units of the war emerging from it: the SAS, the LRDG, the Desert Rats, etc. etc. etc. Things would have been very different in India and Burma, and potentially even Oz, if the Suez Canal had fallen.Finished The Phantom Major this morning. Excellent read.
Yeah it's importance is often over looked. Mrs B and I went to "His House" yesterday to drop off some donations and as always I do a quick perusing of the book section. Picked this up for .50 cents, I always like to grab any historical book with local favor.North Africa was a fascinating campaign. It was almost the British Army version of Guadalcanal (except that it lasted for three years), with so many of the most storied units of the war emerging from it: the SAS, the LRDG, the Desert Rats, etc. etc. etc. Things would have been very different in India and Burma, and potentially even Oz, if the Suez Canal had fallen.
Love those regional gems. The cover reminds me of a story I wrote years ago (I was a journalist for 15 years before moving to marketing and PR in higher ed, which is what I do now) for Memorial Day about a local vet who was an 8th Air Force B-17 gunner; 10 missions before being shot down, captured and spending the last year of the war in a Luftwaffe prison camp.Yeah it's importance is often over looked. Mrs B and I went to "His House" yesterday to drop off some donations and as always I do a quick perusing of the book section. Picked this up for .50 cents, I always like to grab any historical book with local favor.
View attachment 2340
Hey we all have our tastes. I personally can't understand how anyone can be as thoroughly interested in these military history books as the folks here seem to be.Right now, it's a logic puzzle book. Yes, I'm a nerd...